Pins and Needles in Your Hands? Your Wrist Might Not Be the Problem
When someone comes into my office with numbness and tingling in their hand, they've usually already been told it could be carpal tunnel.
Sometimes they're told surgery is the next step by their GP, and they see me for a second opinion.
And almost always, nobody has examined their neck.
Being completely fair, it is normal to assume that most tingling in the hands are symptoms of carpal tunnel syndrome. If you've been given that diagnosis after thorough investigation and testing, there's a high chance that diagnosis is correct.
But not always. And the way to tell isn't the hand. It's where the symptoms start and how they travel.
This article is about how to work out where your symptoms are actually coming from, and how to get them addressed.
Where pins and needles in hands actually comes from
Pins and needles, sharp, shooting pains, or burning sensations in the hand means a nerve is irritated somewhere along its path. The question is where.
At the wrist. This is carpal tunnel syndrome. The median nerve passes through a narrow tunnel at your wrist. When that space is crowded or inflammed, the nerve gets squashed.
At the neck. Nerve roots leave your spine between the vertebrae in your neck. If one of those roots is irritated or compressed, you can feel symptoms down the arm, and sometimes all the way into the fingers. This is called cervical radiculopathy.
At both. This happens less commonly, but we'll still cover it.
The important thing is that these all require different treatment methods. A wrist splint does nothing for a nerve being compressed at your neck. And neck treatment is less likely to directly impact carpal tunnel syndrome.
Treating the wrong one is why some people get a splint, feel no change, and are told the next step is surgery.

How to tell the difference
This is the part most people have never been walked through.
Carpal tunnel usually looks like this. Symptoms sit in the thumb, index and middle fingers, and often half the ring finger. The little finger is usually spared. It's typically worse at night and wakes people up. Shaking the hand out often helps. Symptoms stay in the hand and wrist.
Neck-related symptoms usually look different. And this is the bit worth paying attention to.
When the problem is at your neck, the symptoms usually travel. People describe having some kind of neck and shoulder pain which runs down the arm. Sometimes it stops at the elbow. Sometimes it carries all the way into the fingers.
That travelling pattern is the clue. Carpal tunnel doesn't involve your arm from your neck. It starts at the wrist and hand, and stays in that area
Neck-related symptoms also tend to change with neck position. Looking up, turning your head, or holding your head forward for a while can make them worse. People often notice their symptoms are worse after a long drive or a day at their desk.
There's research backing this up. One study compared people with carpal tunnel alone against people who had both conditions. Pain in the neck, shoulder and upper arm was significantly more common when the neck was also involved.
So if your tingling comes with neck pain, shoulder blade pain, or aching down the arm, that combination is meaningful.
When it's both at once
The two conditions rarely happoen at the same time. A study using a database covering over 90 million patients found that around 10% of people with cervical radiculopathy also had carpal tunnel syndrome.
More importantly, people with a neck problem were nearly four times more likely to also have carpal tunnel than matched controls without one.
This is what's medically referred to as a double crush syndrome. The idea is that a nerve compressed at one point becomes more vulnerable to compression further along.
I'll be honest about the state of the evidence here. The association is well documented, but the proposed mechanism is still debated. Some researchers have found support for it and others haven't. Reported rates vary enormously between studies, partly because there's no agreed definition.
What isn't debated is the practical point. If both sites are involved and you only treat one, you'll get a partial result at best.
That's often the story behind "the surgery helped a bit, but not completely."
Why the neck gets missed
There's a simple reason. The symptoms are in the hand, so that's where people look.
Your hand is also easier to test. Wrist tests are quick, nerve conduction studies focus on the wrist, and the diagnosis is familiar.
But the nerves supplying your hand start in your neck. If nobody examines the neck, a neck problem can't be found.
In my clinic, I see people who've had months of wrist treatment without anyone testing their cervical spine. Not because anyone did anything wrong, but because the investigation wasn't thorough enough.
It's the same pattern I wrote about with hip pain and with sciatica. The place you hurt may not always the place where the problem is coming from.

What makes the neck a likely source
A few things raise the odds that your neck is involved.
Your symptoms travel down the arm rather than starting at the wrist.
You have neck or shoulder pain alongside the hand symptoms.
Position changes things. Looking up, turning your head, or long periods at a screen make it worse.
Both hands are affected, particularly if it's followed a period of heavy screen or desk work.
You've had wrist treatment that didn't help, or helped only partially.
Your little finger is involved. The median nerve doesn't supply it, so persistent little finger symptoms point elsewhere.
None of these confirm anything on their own. But together they're a strong reason to have your neck examined before anyone operates on your wrist.
The posture connection
There's a reason I see a lot of this.
The nerve roots that supply your arm exit the lower part of your neck, around the C5 to C8 levels. When the neck loses its natural curve and the head carries forward, load concentrates at exactly those levels.
A study found that loss of the neck curve was present in roughly 42% of people with neck pain. The degree of curve loss was directly linked to how quickly the discs wore down.
That's the same structural pattern I've written about in the neck pain and posture articles. When the structure changes, the nerve roots at those levels take more pressure than they should.
For some people, that's where the hand symptoms begin.
One thing you can test today
Here's a rough check. It isn't a diagnosis, but it's informative.
Sit upright. Gently tip your head back and turn it toward the side your symptoms are on. Hold it for a few seconds.
If that reproduces or worsens the tingling in your arm or hand, that gives you evidence that the neck could be involved. This movement narrows the space the nerves leaving your neck travel through.
Now try the opposite. Lift the arm on the affected side and rest your hand on top of your head.
If that relieves your symptoms, that's another clue pointing at the neck. Taking tension off the nerve root at the shoulder often eases neck-related symptoms, and it does nothing for true carpal tunnel.
If neither changes anything, your symptoms are more likely coming from the wrist.
Stop immediately if either test causes sharp pain, dizziness, or symptoms in both arms. And take what you notice to your assessment rather than acting on it alone.

Where to start
If you've got pins and needles in your hands and nobody has examined your neck, that's the gap worth closing before any decision about surgery.
Our ClearSpine Pain Assessment is $59, normally $109. We perform five targeted tests designed to work out where the nerve is actually being irritated. They show whether your neck is involved and what the realistic path forward looks like.
And if we can't help you, we'll tell you and refer you to someone who can. No fee for that conversation.
I see people from across Melbourne's southeast, including Berwick, Cranbourne, Narre Warren, Officer and Beaconsfield, here at the clinic in Clyde North.
📍 65 Matterhorn Drive, Clyde North VIC 3978 📞 (03) 5915 9895
Your hand is where you feel it, but that isn't always where it's problem is coming from.
Dr. Ashley Cherrett (BAppSc(Chiro), BHlthSc) is the principal chiropractor and owner of Cherrett Chiropractic in Clyde North, Melbourne. He practises using the Chiropractic BioPhysics (CBP) technique, a structured, evidence-based approach to spinal correction. This article is educational and does not constitute medical advice. Individual results vary, and all care is based on individual assessment.





Comments